beauty tips Brown vs. Black Mascara: Find the Perfect Match for Your Eyes

For as long as women have been enhancing their eyes, a debate has been ongoing about what the best mascara colour should be: black or brown. There are many philosophies and schools of thought surrounding this conversation. It could be as simple as preference. Do you prefer brown with your fair skin for a more natural look? Do you think black contrasts your fair skin more and makes your lashes stand out?

You can stick to preference or follow this simple guide on which mascara best suits your eye colour. Whichever shade you choose, know that our lash-loving, fan-favourite Lash Fixation Length & Definition Tubing Mascara delivers nourishing ingredients in a long-wear, smudge-proof formula.

What’s the Difference Between Brown and Black Mascara?

Our Lash Fixation Length & Definition Tubing Mascara comes in a rich, bold Black and a sumptuous dark Brown. You could stick to one of the two depending on your preference or you could try both and wear Black for evening and Brown for daytime. The tubing technology in both shades of Lash Fixation mascara means you can be confident there will be no smudging or flaking.

Tubing Mascara 101: Why Formula Matters More Than You Think

If you’re new to tubing mascaras, prepare to fall in love! Our Lash Fixation Length & Definition Tubing Mascara has all the benefits of tubing technology and clean beauty in one lash-loving package. Lash Fixation’s tubing technology lifts the lashes as you apply it without clumping or flaking. The tubing technology gives fantastic performance and longevity by wrapping lashes in 360 degree tubes that remove only with warm water. The best part is that the tubes won’t cause stress or breakage on the lashes; we’ve left out harsh ingredients like lacquers and shellacs to produce a gentle formula that nourishes the lashes while delivering bold, stay-put colour.

Best Mascara Shade by Eye Colour

Here are our suggestions for which mascara shade will work best for your eye colour. But remember, if we’re suggesting the opposite of your go-to routine, don’t fret, stick to what you love! Mascara shades are all about preference!

Best Mascara for Blue Eyes

Try Lash Fixation mascara in Black if you have blue eyes. The extra definition that Black offers will bring even more attention to your baby blues.

Best Mascara for Green Eyes

Try Lash Fixation mascara in Brown if you have green eyes. The warm, rich pigment of Brown will contrast your eyes, making them pop!

Best Mascara for Hazel Eyes

Try Lash Fixation mascara in Brown if you have hazel eyes. The green undertones to your eyes will be emphasised by the warm tones of Brown.

Best Mascara for Brown Eyes

Try Lash Fixation mascara in Black if you have brown eyes. The bold pigment of Black will define the eyes.

Best Mascara for Grey Eyes

Try Lash Fixation mascara in Black if you have grey eyes. The cool tones in your eyes will be complemented by the rich colour of Black.

Which One Is Right for You?

We love BOTH Lash Fixation Length & Definition Tubing Mascara in Brown AND Black. They both deliver lash-loving, lash-defining colour! Choose your go-to shade based on your mood, your eye colour, your preference, it’s totally up to you! Try both shades of this tubing mascara must-have to find your favourite!

Shawn Towne

National Makeup Artist and Senior Educator - Shawn Towne's interest in creating beauty began as a teenager growing up in San Antonio, Texas where, as he wryly says, there wasn't much of a beauty industry. Since then, his more than 30 years as a licensed esthetician and cosmetologist have given him the opportunity to work in Los Angeles, Miami and New York as well as travel extensively around the world, gaining experience in editorial, film, television and high-fashion runway makeup and developing a personal passion for helping mature women achieve a healthy, more youthful appearance with makeup. With images, mentions and accredited articles in Allure, InStyle, Town and Country, Marie Claire, LesNouvelles, DAYSPA and American Spa, Shawn has become a recognised expert in the beauty industry.